Insalata Caprese

It was 1992 and I made my maiden trip to Naples, Italy to visit my husband when I stumbled on “Insalata Caprese.” What – this is a salad? Who knew there could be variations.

As a child, I was used to salads consisting of that pale green and yellowish stuff called iceberg with maybe some carrots, radishes, a few tomatoes and trans fat laden bottled dressing. I had no idea something so fresh and yet so simple could be so good. That first bite of mozzarella di bufala was almost an outer body experience. It was like nothing I had ever tasted and just seemed to smoothly run down my throat. The contrast of the sweet, fresh, tomatoes that the Campania region is famous for along with sprigs of fresh basil, olive oil and the perfect amount of salt was what has kept me on the quest for more.

Fast forward to 2007 when I found myself moving to Naples and ecstatic at the prospect of tasting all the wonderful food (and wine 🙂 ) Italy has to offer.

Of course, I returned to the quest for more caprese and found that there are even slight variations on this salad…..some come with oregano instead of basil, some with a squeeze of fresh lemon, some chunk the tomatoes and mozzarella, and some slice them. The key ingredients – tomatoes and mozzarella di bufala – remain the same.

So, after living here for almost two years, I not only have my favorite way of making “Insalata Caprese,” I can actually tell the difference between good mozzarella di bufala and bad. Now, before I get the Italians mad at me, let me clarify. By bad, I don’t actually mean it is indigestible, I mean, it is not my preference. Because what I’ve also learned from living here is that many people have different opinions about what makes good mozzarella di bufala. Some prefer it slightly firm, some think salt destroys it, some only buy it from the town they live in or even more specific, from the same vendor they’ve been buying it from for years (because so-and-so’s brother owns the caseficio).

I can’t say I’m much different because I have tried almost all the shops that sell it in my town and can even tell who makes it slightly firm, with little or no salt, etc. Now, many Italians would probably think I’m crazy (although admire me for sticking to my personal quest for the best) but I don’t buy my mozzarella from any of the shops in my town. Instead, I drive to a nearby town and buy mine from a local Caseficio which, in my opinion, produces the most perfectly balanced, melt-in-your-mouth, mozzarella di bufala I have ever tasted. Add the freshest tomatoes, ripped (not cut) basil, enough salt to compensate for the exquisitely sweet tomatoes, top quality extra virgin olive oil and that, my friend, is what the love of food is all about! My quest has come to a very happy end!

Recipe: Insalata Caprese

2 servings
1 large ball mozzarella di bufala
8 cherry tomatoes, quartered
2 large leaves basil
extra virgin olive oil
kosher or sea salt
Cut mozzarella in half then each half into 4 pieces. Place on a serving dish with the tomatoes. Rip fresh basil over the insalata and drizzle extra virgin olive oil on every piece of mozzarella and tomato. Sprinkle salt to taste making sure you generously sprinkle on the tomatoes if they are sweet. Serve immediately.


4 thoughts on “Insalata Caprese”

  1. RE – Fine Italian Pottery – New Affiliate Program at PepperJam

    Dear Julie,

    We have just joined Pepperjam Network and launched affiliate program. We are now in the process of proactively screening the sites we would like to partner with, since we believe that having a common target and/or working in a complementary category can really make a difference for our businesses.

    You are receiving this message because we wish to have – from the very start – a personal contact with our selected partners vs sending out a message to all the non-joined PJ publishers. Time consuming? Maybe. Certainly you deserve it, though.

    Please, do take some time to evaluate our company, the uniqueness of our selling proposition and the program we offer. We are determined to developing strategic partnerships with our partners, loyal to our motto “when you succeed, we succed”.

    Our company
    By featuring a 4,000 piece collection of fine Italian pottery, we are one of the largest on line webstores in the category, rightly renowned in the US for its quality and the services it offers.

    Our range of products includes Italian dinnerware, tableware, decoration accents and prized collectible pieces, handmade by talented craftsmen and artists from Umbria (Deruta and Gubbio), Tuscany and Sicily.

    Large pictures and thorough descriptions provide an easy and exciting shopping and learning experience. The Free Personalization and Special Order services allow the US Customer to commission the craftsmen for personalized or tailor made ceramics, just like Italians have been doing since the Renaissance.

    Our affiliate program
    You may want to review our program in private! We’ll send you an offer though PJ platform, where you’ll also find our best selling creatives and product feed.

    Please, contact us at You can count on a timely answer from Tiziana or Manuela. Please note that we are based in Italy, i.e +6 to +9 vs US time zones.

    Looking forward to working with you!

    Tiziana Manzetti
    Fine Italian Ceramics chosen out of passion

  2. sounds delicious Julie! This is Walt… your long lost brother-n-law from good ole MS HAHA… so I’m starting to venture my tastes into wines, and I might have to dab in your vast knowledge of the wines and such haha hope all is well!

  3. Yum yum! Next time you’re headed to your “local caseficio” let me know. I’d love to find out your secret place! :0)

Comments are closed.